Book Review: Mad Mabel by Sally Hepworth

✨ Quick Book Details

Title: Mad Mabel
Author: Sally Hepworth
Genre: Mystery / Thriller / Domestic Mystery
Format: Audiobook / Hardcover
Pages: 352
Publication Date: April 21, 2026
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐


πŸ“– Synopsis (Spoiler-Free)

Everyone knows Elsie “Mabel” Fitzpatrick as the grumpy eighty-one-year-old woman who’s lived on the same street for decades and somehow always knows everyone’s business. But when one of her neighbors dies under suspicious circumstances, Mabel becomes the focus of a murder investigation. As detectives dig into her past, long-buried secrets begin to surface, leaving everyone wondering whether Mabel is simply misunderstood…or capable of murder.


πŸ’­ My Thoughts

There are two kinds of people no one ever expects to be murderers: little girls and old ladies. Mad Mabel takes that idea and runs with it in the best possible way.

From the very beginning, I was hooked by the mystery, but what kept me turning the pages wasn’t just trying to solve the crime—it was getting to know Mabel herself.

One of my favorite things about this book was the dual timeline. We follow Mabel’s story through the “Then” chapters, where we witness her difficult childhood, and the “Now” chapters, where she’s navigating a modern-day murder investigation. Sally Hepworth reveals just enough information at the right moments to keep the suspense building without ever making the twists feel forced.

Young Mabel completely broke my heart. Her childhood is filled with loss, trauma, loneliness, and relentless cruelty, and watching those experiences slowly shape the woman she becomes added so much emotional depth to the story. Every chapter revealed another piece of her life that made me understand her just a little bit more.

What surprised me most was how deeply I came to care about Mabel. Beneath her sharp tongue and grumpy exterior is a woman who has spent her entire life surviving. Her friendship with seven-year-old Persephone became one of my favorite parts of the novel. Their relationship brought warmth, humor, and tenderness to an otherwise suspenseful story, and it revealed a fiercely protective side of Mabel that made her impossible not to root for.

By the end, I found myself thinking less about whether Mabel was “mad” and more about everything she had endured. This is more than a mystery—it’s a thoughtful story about resilience, survival, and how childhood wounds can shape an entire lifetime.


❤️ What I Loved

  • Dual timelines that kept me invested from beginning to end
  • A complex, unforgettable main character
  • Emotional depth alongside a compelling mystery
  • The friendship between Mabel and Persephone
  • Well-paced reveals that kept me guessing


πŸ€” Things to Consider

If you’re looking for a fast-paced, action-heavy thriller, this may not be exactly what you’re expecting. This is a slower, character-driven mystery where the emotional journey is just as important as solving the crime.


πŸ“š Final Thoughts

Mad Mabel is proof that the best mysteries aren’t always about discovering who committed the crime—they’re about discovering who people really are.

If you enjoy character-driven mysteries, dual timelines, complicated female protagonists, and stories that balance suspense with genuine emotional depth, this is one worth adding to your TBR.

Final Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Would I Recommend It? 

Absolutely—especially if you love mysteries where the characters stay with you long after you’ve turned the final page.


Comments